Unlocking Trauma: The Healing Power and Pitfalls of Physical Release

Releasing Trauma: The Power and Pitfalls of Physical Expression

The type of therapy that often included activities like punching or screaming to release trauma is commonly associated with Primal Therapy, developed by Dr. Arthur Janov in the late 1960s. Primal Therapy is based on the concept that repressed pains and traumas from childhood can be brought to the surface and addressed through re-experiencing those moments and expressing the repressed emotions associated with them—often loudly and vigorously, including crying, screaming, and other forms of visceral expression.

Another related approach is Bioenergetics, developed by Alexander Lowen. It is a form of body psychotherapy that combines work with physical exercises, including punching or kicking, to release muscular tension and blocked emotions. This therapy is based on the belief that emotional issues are reflected in the body’s posture and muscle structure, and that addressing these physical aspects can help release emotional trauma. Both therapies stem from the broader movement of expression-based therapies that emerged as part of the human potential movement, which emphasized the therapeutic release of suppressed emotions.

These therapies were quite groundbreaking at their inception, proposing that such cathartic physical expressions could lead to significant psychological relief and healing.

Trauma leaves an indelible mark on the body and mind, shaping how we respond to stress and emotions long after the traumatic event has passed. One approach to addressing trauma involves physical expression—punching, screaming, crying—to release pent-up emotions. While these methods can offer immediate relief, it’s important to consider both the pros and cons through neurophysiological and trauma-informed lenses.

The Neurophysiological Perspective

Pros of Physical Expression

1. Immediate Release: Engaging in physical activities like punching or screaming can provide an immediate outlet for intense emotions. This release can reduce the immediate sensation of emotional pressure and offer a temporary sense of relief.
2. Activation of the Parasympathetic Nervous System: Physical exertion followed by rest can activate the parasympathetic nervous system, promoting a state of relaxation and recovery. This can help in temporarily reducing the hyperarousal often associated with trauma.
3. Endorphin Release: Physical activities can trigger the release of endorphins, the body’s natural painkillers, which can improve mood and provide a sense of well-being.

Cons of Physical Expression

1. Reinforcement of Trauma Circuits: The approach of re-experiencing traumatic emotions through intense expression (like screaming or punching) was originally thought to help by releasing pent-up emotions. However, modern neuroscience suggests some nuances: Reinforcement of Trauma Circuits: Repeatedly activating the traumatic memory and associated emotional responses can reinforce the existing neural pathways rather than alleviate them. This can make the brain more likely to trigger these pathways in future stress responses, potentially exacerbating symptoms of trauma rather than healing them.
2. Lack of New Learning: Effective trauma therapy involves not just expressing emotions but integrating and reprocessing them in a way that reduces their emotional impact. Simply re-experiencing the emotions without a structured, supportive context may fail to foster the new neural pathways needed for healing.
3. Potential for Re-Traumatization: Intense physical expressions can sometimes lead to re-traumatization, especially if not properly managed within a therapeutic setting. This can reinforce feelings of helplessness and distress rather than alleviating them.

The Trauma-Informed Perspective

Pros of Physical Expression

1. Empowerment: Physical expression can empower individuals by providing them with an active role in their healing process. It allows them to reclaim their bodies and assert control over their emotional states.
2. Somatic Release: Trauma is often stored in the body, and physical expression can help release this stored tension. Techniques like somatic experiencing acknowledge the importance of addressing the physical manifestations of trauma.
3. Enhanced Awareness: Engaging in physical expression can enhance bodily awareness, helping individuals become more attuned to their physical and emotional states. This can be a crucial step in the healing process.

Cons of Physical Expression

1. Safety Concerns: A trauma-informed approach emphasizes safety and stability. Intense physical expressions can sometimes feel overwhelming or unsafe for individuals, particularly if they are not adequately prepared or supported.
2. Lack of Integration: For true healing, it’s essential to integrate the emotional and physical experiences. Without proper therapeutic guidance, individuals might not be able to process and make sense of their emotions, leading to temporary relief without long-term benefits. New behaviors creating new neural pathways must be practiced with mindfulness and consistency.
3. Risk of Maladaptive Patterns: Engaging in physical expression without addressing the underlying trauma can lead to maladaptive patterns. Instead of resolving the trauma, individuals might develop a dependency on these expressions for temporary relief, without addressing the root cause.

How Gestalt Therapy Aligns with Psychedelic-Assisted Psychotherapy

• Emphasis on Awareness: Gestalt therapy helps clients become more aware of their feelings and behaviors in the present moment. This heightened awareness can be particularly effective in psychedelic sessions, leading to profound insights and emotional breakthroughs.

• Holistic View: Gestalt therapy views individuals as complete wholes, considering body, mind, and emotions. This holistic approach aligns with psychedelic therapy, where experiences often transcend ordinary mental processes and involve somatic and emotional dimensions.

• Experiential Techniques: Techniques like role-playing or the empty chair can be useful during the integration phase of psychedelic therapy, helping individuals process and integrate their psychedelic experiences into their regular lives.

• Dialogue and Encounter: The authentic encounter between client and therapist fosters an environment of trust and openness, crucial for creating a safe space during the potentially vulnerable states induced by psychedelics.

Conclusion

While physical expression can offer immediate relief and serve as a powerful tool for trauma release, it’s essential to approach it with a nuanced understanding of its potential benefits and drawbacks. Integrating these expressions within a supportive, structured therapeutic framework, such as IFS, EFT, ACT, ACE, Narrative therapy, Gestalt therapy, Compassionate Inquiry, Jungian Therapy and many others, can enhance their effectiveness and promote long-term healing. By balancing immediate emotional release with deeper integration and reprocessing, individuals can foster healthier neural pathways and achieve more sustainable recovery from trauma.
Schedule a Free Consultation with me